As we look ahead to 2025, it’s essential to reflect on the year gone by. 2024 was a year of challenges and triumphs for the short-term rental industry, defined by resilience, innovation, and a commitment to growth. From navigating strict regulations to capitalizing on new revenue opportunities, STR operators have showcased their ability to adapt and thrive in an ever-evolving landscape. Let’s dive into The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly of 2024 and explore strategies shaping the coming year.
The Ugly: Regulations and Natural Disasters
STR Regulations have posed significant challenges in 2024. Permit requirements, occupancy bylaws, new short-term rental limits – STR operators have faced an uphill battle.
According to Brian Chesskiy, 80% of Airbnb’s top 200 markets by revenue already have some regulation.
France’s 2025 regulations will reduce tax breaks, cap rentals at 90 days per year, and enforce mandatory property registration with penalties for non-compliance.
Spain is launching a national registration system requiring property codes, local approvals, and increased oversight.
Australia is introducing similar measures with national registration and annual limits of 60–180 rental days.
We saw tightening regulations in North America. In Canada, British Columbia is restricting STRs to principal residences with business licenses and steep fines starting May 2024.
In the US, states like Florida, California, Colorado, and Massachusetts proposed new restrictions, while New York City effectively banned STRs entirely. Urban markets are particularly impacted, with inventory reductions and rising compliance costs.
Regulations are a source of frustration for many operators, showing that the industry is becoming more challenging. However, some see a silver lining. By limiting lower-quality rentals, regulations help create a more professional market. They also improve safety standards, which benefit both guests and the broader community.
Adding to these challenges, natural disasters such as hurricanes, wildfires, floods, and heatwaves wreaked havoc in vulnerable regions, disrupting operations and altering traveler behavior. Operators in urban areas like San Francisco and coastal towns faced unique challenges as local communities pushed for stricter local laws to mitigate the impact of short-term rentals.
Contingency planning, dynamic pricing tools, and building operational resilience will be crucial for STR operators navigating an unpredictable landscape.
The Bad: Persistent Issues and Emerging Concerns
Market Saturation and Competition
The short-term rental market is increasingly competitive, with 76% of respondents in Hostaway’s survey reporting heightened competition in 2024. In Guesty’s Report 55% of short-term rental operators cite market saturation as a major challenge. Although slightly lower than the previous year, this remains a significant concern.
To stand out in a saturated market, operators must differentiate their properties with unique value propositions and enhanced guest experiences.
Adjusting pricing and leveraging additional revenue streams, such as upsells or fees, can often serve as an effective competitive strategy.
Economic Factors
Uncertainties in the economy are top of mind for property managers. According to KeyData STR Outlook 2025, a potential slowdown or decreased demand worries 89% of operators, impacting revenue and growth. Demand fluctuations further require flexible strategies to adapt to changing market conditions.
While some operators report increased average daily rates (ADR), others are seeing declines. Pricing pressures are pushing many property managers to lower rates to remain competitive, while rising operational costs pose a challenge.
Operational and Logistical Issues
Staffing remains a pain point, with property managers struggling to find and retain reliable cleaning and maintenance staff. The rising demand for skilled workers has only amplified these challenges. Both Hostaway’s and Guesty’s surveys show staffing is a top-five challenge for short-term rental managers..
Technology, while a valuable tool, also presents hurdles. About 45% of Hostaway’s survey cited technology integration, highlighting challenges in consolidating multiple tools into a cohesive system. Cleaning and maintenance remain persistent concerns across the industry.
Shifting Consumer Behavior
Travelers’ booking habits continued to evolve in 2024, with shorter booking windows becoming the norm. Increased spontaneity means operators must adapt with last-minute strategies to maximize occupancy. Guests are also raising the bar for quality. They expect short-term rentals to offer a blend of uniqueness and the consistent service they’d find in hotels.
Rising Business Costs
According to Guesty’s Industry Report, larger rental management companies ranked cost management as their biggest challenge, followed by competition and staffing shortages. Meanwhile, Hostaway’s Report highlighted growth and scaling as key pain points for short-term rental business owners.
Despite these hurdles, there was good news:
- AirDNA reported that occupancy rates stopped declining, and revenue per available rental (RevPAR) returned to positive growth after two years of decline.
- Slower supply growth, coupled with a 7% rebound in demand, restored balance to the market, enabling property management companies to regain pricing power with rising average daily rates (ADR).
However, fierce competition remains a key issue. Since 2020, the supply of active Airbnb rental listings in the U.S. has surged by 62%, largely driven by new investors (Hostfully). The influx of low-quality listings and aggressive price-cutting strategies has intensified the need for operators to stand out while maintaining profitability.
Shorter booking windows added complexity, requiring rental property managers to frequently adjust pricing strategies. According to KeyData, 83% of property managers reported changing prices at least once a week, further emphasizing the importance of dynamic pricing tools in addressing demand fluctuations.
The Good: Resilience and New Revenue Opportunities
If 2024 taught us anything, it’s that STR operators can grow in tough markets. Even in declining markets like Atlanta, property managers found ways to grow by leveraging dynamic pricing and driving incremental revenue through upsells, add-ons and fees.
- Our data shows that upsells generated up to $147 per listing per month in extra revenue
- Over the past year, the volume of Upsells for the Enso Connect users has grown by +500%.
- Early check-ins, late check-outs and damage waivers were the biggest revenue drivers.
Top 2025 Revenue Trends: Set-jetting, event-driven travel, pet-friendly stays, price sensitivity, flexible access, and damage waivers.
RevLabs workshop, HomeToGo Survey and Skift Megatrends revealed new trends driving revenue in 2025:
Emerging trends also shaped new opportunities for short-term rental owners:
- Experiential travel. Guests increasingly sought unique accommodations and memorable guest experiences, sparking trends like set-jetting (visiting destinations from popular movies) and event-driven travel (e.g., concerts, festivals, and global sporting events). Unique, hands-on experiences drive decisions for 21% of travelers.
- People are also looking to travel with pets, and pet fees are becoming more common.
- Wellness and mental health-focused accommodations gained traction, reflecting travelers’ growing preference for long-term health benefits and extended periods of relaxation.
-
Travelers are eager for their money to go further – 36% of respondents prioritize price.
-
Business Insider shares another hospitality industry trend. As travelers spend less on cheap Airbnbs, high-end vacation rentals are booming.
STR operators with competitive pricing and unique experiences in their listings are set to capture more demand in 2025. They can recapture revenue with experiential upsells and convenience add-ons, enhancing both profitability and guest satisfaction.
Guest satisfaction remained a priority, with STR operators focusing on delivering positive reviews through improved cleaning fees, house rules, and personalized services. Platforms like Airbnb and other short-term rental platforms emphasized the importance of online reviews and local partnerships to boost visibility and attract ideal guests.
The Bet on AI
AI continues to divide opinions in the vacation rental industry. Some see its immense potential, while others question the practical use cases, ROI, and speed of delivering real value to operators.
Since early 2023, the industry has followed a typical AI adoption journey, reflecting the phases of Gartner’s Hype Cycle. Initially, there was a surge of excitement and high expectations around AI’s potential, as operators were eager to explore its capabilities. As challenges and limitations surfaced, enthusiasm dipped into skepticism and disappointment. Now, the industry is transitioning to a more balanced perspective, understanding the practical applications of AI and beginning to see real, tangible value through thoughtful implementation. This shift marks the move toward sustained growth and confidence in AI as a transformative tool.
Guesty’s survey revealed that 52% of vacation rental property managers are already using AI, with key applications including dynamic pricing, guest communication (33%), and content creation (23%).
Simon Lehmann predicts that in 2025, vendors who successfully provide tangible AI solutions will lead the market. Meanwhile, Ela Mezhiborsky from Autohost highlights the growing threat of AI-driven fraud, emphasizing the need for tech solutions to combat it.
In 2024, AI advanced more than in the past years combined. This will undoubtedly impact its applications in the short-term rental industry. We are working towards and anticipating more solid case studies from hospitality professionals leveraging this technology. The future of AI in our industry depends on solving real challenges and delivering measurable results.
Looking Ahead: Turning the Tables on 2025
The STR market in 2025 holds promise for operators ready to adapt to evolving dynamics and capitalize on new opportunities. Here are key strategies to consider:
1. Automate and Optimize
Smart automation and AI will remain critical for scaling efficiently, maximizing cash flow, and delivering personalized guest experiences. PropTech solutions are enabling operators to enhance operational efficiency while maintaining a human touch. For example, AI-driven tools for sentiment analysis can help operators respond to online reviews more effectively and identify patterns to improve service.
2. Focus on Upsells
Upselling opportunities, from operational add-ons to local partnerships, can help operators grow revenue without adding new rental properties. For instance, offering wellness-focused packages or partnering with local businesses can cater to niche markets and enhance the guest experience.
3. Target Unique Niches
Tailoring rental listings for specific demographics, such as multi-generational travelers or wellness-focused guests, can attract high-value bookings. Trends like wellness tourism and eco-friendly accommodations are gaining momentum and offer lucrative opportunities. In addition, event-driven travel and set-jetting are expected to drive demand in 2025.
4. Strengthen Marketing and Distribution
Short-term rental hosts are increasingly relying on targeted marketing strategies and diversified booking channels to remain competitive. Direct bookings, Airbnb, and Vrbo remain top channels, but operators are also exploring additional platforms to reduce reliance on any single source. Data-driven marketing can further refine these efforts by identifying high-value segments and crafting compelling offers.
5. Adapt to Regulatory Changes
Staying ahead of emerging regulations will be crucial for success. Short-term rental management companies should proactively implement tools and procedures to ensure compliance while advocating for fair policies that balance community and industry needs. Building strong local networks and promoting community-based initiatives can further enhance operator reputation and guest trust.
6. Leverage Data for Profitability
With demand projected to outpace supply, profitability will become the north star of the STR industry. Leveraging market intelligence and benchmarking tools can help operators optimize rates, retain property owners, and make confident growth decisions. For instance, KeyData highlights the importance of monitoring key performance indicators (KPIs) like Average Daily Rate (ADR), Adjusted Paid Occupancy (APO), and Revenue per Available Rental (RevPAR).
Final Thoughts
2024 was a year of resilience and transformation for the STR industry. While regulatory pressures, natural disasters, and rising costs posed significant challenges, operators demonstrated creativity and adaptability, laying the groundwork for future success.
As we enter 2025, the focus will shift to profitability, personalization, and leveraging technology to unlock new revenue streams. With demand projected to outpace supply and the global STR market expected to reach $256.3 billion by 2030 (11.2% annual growth rate, Guesty), the opportunities are vast.
By staying attuned to market trends, embracing innovation, and prioritizing guest satisfaction, STR professionals can turn challenges into opportunities and make 2025 a year where the Good outshines the Bad and the Ugly.
Stay tuned for more valuable insights and tools to help you thrive in the coming year, capturing more rental income while creating unforgettable guest experiences for short-term rental guests.
See how Enso Connect can fuel your growth in 2025
